Beginning with the Most Recent
- Chad Dutz: 2015 - Current
- David Nondorf: 2004 - 2015
- Thomas Steindler Sr.: 2000 - 2004
- Carroll Walls: 1996 - 2000
- Phillip Griffith: 1988 - 1996
- Larry Linton: 1984 - 1988
- Billy Butterfield: 1976 - 1984
- Stanley Conner: 1955 - 1976
- Wilbur Cowdrey: 1943 - 1955
- Harry Clindedinst: 1942 - 1943
- John Marks: 1930 - 1942
- Fred Wittenburg: 1926 - 1930
- William Forney: 1924 - 1926
- Jesse Wise: 1922 - 1924
- Lyman Dean: 1915 - 1921
- John Holman: 1912 - 1913
- Jesse Wise: 1911 - 1912
- John Holman: 1911
- Jesse Wise: 1905 - 1910
- Will Newland: 1898 - 1905
- William Edwards: 1897
- Will Newland: 1897
- L.T. White: 1893 - 1897
- William Drago: 1889 - 1893
- William Emery Brown: 1885 - 1887
- William Emery Brown: 1882
- Robert Jones: 1880
- William Kellogg: 1880
- William Drago: 1877
- John Kellogg: 1875
- J.W. Kellogg 1869
- John Halsey: First Fire Chief 1867
Source: "A Walk Through Time With The Valparaiso Fire Department"
Pages: 259 - 260
Historian/Former Battalion Chief Gene Spencer